The risks of withdrawing committed financing from an insolvent company
Last December, the Spanish Supreme Court (“SC”) ordered two major Spanish banks to compensate an insolvent company that ultimately went into liquidation, for having deprived it of the opportunity to reach an arrangement with its creditors and, consequently, to continue its business activity (judgment 1944/2025 of 23 December).
The company had long relied on account receivables discounting agreements with several financial institutions, including the two banks mentioned. However, following the opening of the insolvency proceedings in July 2011, these banks refused to further advance payment of the receivables.
The insolvent company sought to reach an arrangement with its creditors that would enable it to keep operating in the market. According to a viability plan submitted in August 2011, this would require maintaining existing financing, refinancing the debt, restructuring the business and reducing expenses.
In January 2012, the company amended its viability plan, citing several reasons, including the loss of receivables discounting as a source of financing, which had adversely affected its working capital availability since October 2011.
In March 2012, the insolvency administrator, with the acquiescence of the company, requested the discontinuation of business activity due to a lack of financing and liquidity, declining sales and insufficient cost reduction. The court approved the request and the company eventually entered into liquidation.
Years later, the company brought a damages action against the two banks, arguing that their breach of the account receivables discounting agreements frustrated the viability plan and, as a result, made it impossible for the creditors to approve an arrangement that would have allowed the company to remain in business.
It claimed that the harm suffered amounted to the difference between the company’s value based on the projections of the initial viability plan and its value according to those of the amended plan, namely €1.2 million, as determined by an expert report.
The first instance and appellate courts dismissed the claim, finding that the banks’ contractual breaches had not been established as the sole or a sufficient cause of the company’s failure to reach an arrangement with its creditors.
However, the SC reversed these rulings by applying the loss of opportunity doctrine, which does not require “absolute certainty” that a benefit would have been obtained or a loss avoided in the absence of the unlawful conduct, but rather a reasonable probability.
The SC found that (i) the company was in an “ideal” position to propose an arrangement that could have been approved by the necessary majority of creditors and (ii) the loss of the committed bank financing led to a drop in sales, which in turn undermined the projections of the viability plan. On this basis, it reached the “reasonable conviction” that there was a “real probability” that, irrespective of other contributing factors, an arrangement could have been reached but for the banks’ breach of contract.
As for the quantification of damages, the SC relied on the expert valuation provided by the claimant as a reference, noting that the defendants merely denied the existence of damages without submitting a better-grounded counter-valuation. Nevertheless, given that, in light of the viability plan and the insolvency administrator’s request for discontinuation of business activity, there were other factors that contributed to depriving the company of the opportunity to continue operating in the market, the SC reduced the amount claimed by 85 per cent.